What is The Best Catcher’s Mitt of 2017? – (Buying Guide & Reviews)

top senior model catcher's mittsTaking a Closer Look at Some Quality Adult and Youth Catcher’s Mitts!

Are you a catcher when you play baseball and looking to give yourself more of an edge when you pay this tough position? Then you know how important it is to have the finest equipment possible when you are behind the plate. Part of that means you need the best catcher’s mitt you can buy to help you field balls in the dirt and also keep the sting away when catching hard thrown pitches.

In this article, we will supply you with information that will help you find a baseball catcher’s mitt that is perfect for you or your youth player. We will also do a series of reviews on the best youth catcher’s mitts and the top senior model catcher’s mitts too.

Reviews of the Top Adult and Youth Catchers Mitts

Here are some informational reviews on what we feel are the very best youth and adult catcher’s mitts in the sports marketplace:

  • 4.3 Customer Rating
  • AllStar CM3000SBT 33.5" Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $$$$$
  • SIZE : 33.5"
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : Tan Leather in Palm Black Leather on Back Adds
  • Color : Black / Brown
  • Feel : Extra Stiff
  • 4.6 Customer Rating
  • Wilson A2000 Pro Stock Pudge 32.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $$$$
  • SIZE : 32.5''
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : Pro Stock(TM) Leather
  • Color : Black / Brown
  • Feel : Unmatched feel
  • 4.8 Customer Rating
  • All-Star Pro-Advanced 33.5 Inch CM3100SBT Baseball Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $$$
  • SIZE : 33.5''
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : Leather
  • Color : Black / Brown
  • Feel : Stiff
  • 4.3 Customer Rating
  • Mizuno Samurai Pro 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $$$
  • SIZE : 34''
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : Full Grain Leather Shell
  • Color : Black
  • Feel : Stiff
  • 4.5 Customer Rating
  • Akadema APP240 ProSoft Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $$
  • SIZE : 33.5''
  • Hand Orientation : Left Hand / Right hand thrower
  • Material : Select Steerhide Leather
  • Color : Black
  • Feel : Game Ready

AllStar CM3000SBT 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt

This elite model catcher’s mitt has a nice blend of affordability and quality. It’s good enough for the serious baseball player to own yet affordable enough that even recreational baseball players can use it too.

It features a nice symmetrical pocket for picking up baseballs out of the dirt and it’s also padded in all the key areas that need protecting. The leather lacing that is found throughout this meet also makes it highly adjustable to fit the hand of the user.

The reinforced black leather backing stiffens it up a little for support and this mitt makes a crisp snapping sound when the baseball goes into it.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    This catcher’s mitt requires very little break in time thanks to its very soft Japanese leather steer hide. It also makes it very comfortable to wear without sacrificing the durability that every catcher’s mitt needs.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    This size model is definitely not for youth players or those individuals with smaller hands. It is so heavily padded that players that do not have strong hands may have trouble closing it too.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Wilson A2000 Pro Stock Pudge 32.5″ Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

You will have a hard time not finding many Wilson baseball products any time you go to a professional or recreational baseball game. Catcher’s mitts that are designed as well as this one are part of the reason the baseball equipment they make is so popular. This is one well-designed baseball catcher’s mitt.

This glove has some exceptional features to it. It has a deep half-moon pocket and the outside padding is thinner to help you scoop up balls better as you play behind the plate. The palm area is slightly extended also to help the glove flex easier too.

This glove is made out of high-quality leather that gives it the rare combination of beings soft but still durable. Its pro baseball pattern is continually updated and improved as necessary.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    You can tell this glove had the help of ex-major league all-star catcher Ivan “Pudge” Rodriguez when it was designed. It has many unique features you do not see in other model catchers mitts. An example of this is its DriLex® wrist lining that helps keep your hand dry as you play the game.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    Those who have bought and used this glove have very few complaints about it. Some catchers do not prefer the looks of its mostly black exterior.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

All-Star Pro-Advanced 33.5 Inch CM3100SBT Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

This is All-Star’s much more budget friendly catcher’s mitt. Just don’t mistake that for meaning it’s not a good quality catcher’s mitt. It is an excellent choice for teens and recreational adult baseball players that like to play behind the plate.

It is a catcher’s mitt that has been pre-oil treated to help its sturdy leather construction get supple quicker. The rawhide laces it features are heavy duty to help prevent them from breaking. It has a nicely padded wrist guard and a Velcro wrist strap so you can make quick fit adjustments when you need them.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    We all thought the pro-style pocket this mitt has and the extended profiled toe on it makes it very easy to scoop up baseballs in the dirt. It’s wider heel channel will also help those whose hands are not as strong close this mitt faster and tighter.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    Some of us here did not like the extremely light colored portions of leather on this catcher’s mitt. Call us old fashioned but we thought it was a little loud for our tastes. Many users also thought this glove took a long time to break in so take that into consideration if you need to use your new catcher’s mitt in a game situation right away.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Mizuno Samurai Pro 34″ Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

There are few names when it comes to baseball products that carry a bigger name than Mizuno. This is a teen or adult catcher’s mitt model from them that’s a great entry level glove for those experimenting with or learning how to play catcher. It is very affordable priced too.

This glove offers a high level of protection as evidenced by its patent-pending thumb guard. There is an abundance of lacing positions found throughout it so you can adjust it to fit easily too.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    This Mizuno catcher’s mitt has a specially designed palm they call a ParaShock palm. It is made to hold up to the shock that repeatedly catching baseball inevitable causes. This catcher’s mitt proprietary designed palm also provides extra padding and comfort when playing behind the plate.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    This particular model is a large glove and only those players with a bigger hand will feel comfortable when using it. Mizuno might want to consider offering this catcher’s mitt in a few colors besides all black too.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Akadema APP240 ProSoft Catcher’s Mitt

Here is another great entry level catcher’s mitt that is perfect for those that are new to the position and unsure if they want to make a huge investment in a top of the line catcher’s mitt. This glove is no slouch though when it comes to catching pitched baseballs and scooping them out of the dirt.

It has a special design where the edge padding is thinned to help trap balls in it better and speed up the glove to hand transfer of the baseball. The proprietary “Double Flexhinge” technology built into this mitt helps this glove quickly snap closed when a baseball strikes it.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    There are two features that impressed us with this budget-friendly catcher’s mitt. One was how very soft the leather used in making it is. This mitt also has a special ‘finger hammocks’ design which helps keep your hand from moving around so much when using it.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    We have a few concerns about the durability of this glove but then again that might be expected at this price point. It is definitely not a glove that serious ballplayers who play many games each week want to purchase.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

  • 4.3 Customer Rating
  • Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Youth Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $$
  • SIZE : 32"
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : U.S. Steerhide Leather Construction (Palm and Web) with AkademaLyte Leather on Back to Reduce Weight
  • Color : Brown
  • Feel : Game Ready
  • 4.9 Customer Rating
  • Mizuno 34" World Win GXC75 Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $$
  • SIZE : 34''
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : Top quality leather and utilizing cutting edge innovations
  • Color : Black / Brown
  • Feel : Game Ready
  • 4.6 Customer Rating
  • Rawlings Renegade Series Catcher’s Mitt, 32.5-Inch
  • PRICE $
  • SIZE : 32.5''
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : High Density Leather Palm Leather Shell & Lacing
  • Color : Black
  • Feel : Game Ready
  • 4.3 Customer Rating
  • Mizuno Supreme GXC94 Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $
  • SIZE : 33.5''
  • Hand Orientation : Right hand thrower
  • Material : Full Grain Leather Shell
  • Color : Black
  • Feel : Game Ready
  • 4.7 Customer Rating
  • Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher's Mitt
  • PRICE $
  • SIZE : 32.5''
  • Hand Orientation : The glove will be on the left hand of the player and they will throw with their right hand.
  • Material : ParaShock Palm Pad
  • Color : Black / Brown
  • Feel : Game Ready

Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Here is a very good entry level youth or young teen catcher’s mitt that is made by Akadema. It is a baseball glove that is both solidly constructed and has some unique design features too.

One of the nice things about this catcher’s mitt model is that it absorbs the shock of a baseball hitting it very well. That makes it very easy on any youth player’s hands and they won’t get discouraged quickly playing the position. This mitt also has Akadema’s patented “Finger Hammocks” design and features nice reduced width padding to help a player pick up a ball thrown in the dirt easier.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    The leather lacing on this glove is found throughout it and is very sturdy, to say the least. That makes this models catcher’s mitt very easy to adjust exactly the way you like it and it will help it hold up better over a long period of time too.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    This glove has kind of a strange light and dark pattern to it that may not appeal to some users. It is a mitt that is a little to the stiff side and will take some time to break in because of that too. Make sure you purchase some glove oil to help counter that when you buy it.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Mizuno 34″ World Win GXC75 Catcher’s Mitt

Here is another quality novice or entry level catcher’s mitt from the reputable Mizuno Company. It is priced at a point where anyone who wants can try their hand at catching in the game of baseball. It is sized so it can fit even players with larger hands.

Like with any Mizuno catcher’s mitt this one has many innovative features built into it. You will like the fact it takes little or no time to break in for one. You will also like the way it snaps shut quickly when a baseball enters into it and how the shock is absorbed nicely when that happens.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    Most of us thought this catcher’s mitt not only will perform well but had a little style to it also. The black on tan design gave it a unique look. The soft feel leather also made it very easy to close and feel the ball when it’s squeezed.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    This mitt is not very heavily padded but then again it’s not really designed for every day or pro baseball players. If you play in a baseball league where the pitchers throw 90+ miles an hour you may want to consider that before you purchase this model catcher’s mitt.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Rawlings Renegade Series Catcher’s Mitt, 32.5-Inch

This is an excellent model catcher’s mitt made by the quality baseball product manufacturer Rawlings. Like with all of their baseball items there were no corners cut when this glove was made. It is a durable model that will help you field the catcher’s position well.

One of the best things about this model baseball glove is its superior lacing. That will make it easily adjustable to fit any youth or teen player’s hands. It is also a catcher’s mitt that is designed to only require a very short break in time before it can be used in a game.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    The fact that this glove is very affordably priced really appealed to us. It is priced low enough that any youth or teen player can buy it and try it as they play behind the plate. If they don’t end up liking the position then they have an affordable mitt to play catch with.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    We were less than thrilled with this catcher’s mitt’s all black design. Rawlings may want to consider making it in more color choices. There may be some durability issues with this glove but that is not unexpected at its very budget friendly price point.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Mizuno Supreme GXC94 Catcher’s Mitt

If you just want your teenage child with big hands to play catch in the back yard with a catcher’s mitt or experiment playing the position in a teen youth league, then this is the perfect catcher’s mitt for that purchase. It’s a better catcher’s mitt than you would expect for its low price point too.

Mizuno likes to refer to this mitt as a ‘transitional’ model for those that have never caught before or have only caught a few games. Its padding is lighter but this glove can be adjusted to fit any larger size youth hand and is very easy to control when playing behind the plate.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    You can tell from our reviews we are not big fans of the look of all black catchers’ mitts but we actually liked this model. It has pretty neat yellow accents found on it that stands out nicely with its black background. Those of us here are also big fans of Mizuno’s ‘ParaShock’ technology too that helps make their catcher’s mitts more durable and comfortable to use.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    You certainly don’t want your teenage ballplayer catching 90+ miles an hour with this glove or they will feel a stinging sensation for sure. This is definitely a lightly padded entry level or novice catcher’s mitt.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Do you want your son or daughter to try playing behind the plate in the game of baseball? Then this is an excellent and affordable model youth catcher’s mitt for doing that. It is perfect for players from 10 – 15 years old with average sized hands.

It is a glove that includes such things as Mizuno’s innovative ParaShock palm pad. That helps make this glove more durable and take some of the force off your child’s hand when the ball hits the glove. Mizuno also made this glove highly adjustable so your youth player can get a comfortable fit too.

  • What we really like about this model catcher’s mitt
    This glove has Mizuno’s unique power close design with a ‘V Flex’ Notch. That makes it super easy for any youth player to feel and squeeze a baseball when it enters into this mitt. That is a big plus for youth players whose hand strength is still growing.
  • Areas for improvement with this product
    Not really recommended for catching pitchers that throw much over 70 mph. We can see some durability issues with this glove as it’s used over a long period of time too. Once again that is not something unusual at this price point.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Handy Baseball Catcher’s Mitt Buying Guide

Best Catcher’s MittHere are the features of a catcher’s mitt that are important to consider if you are shopping for a new one:

7 Things To Consider Before Buying A Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

  1. Size

    Like anything that you ear size is important and it’s true when it comes to catchers mitts too. When a glove is sized properly it fits well and in turn, a good fit gives you much more control over your catcher’s mitt.

    One thing that you must note when sizing a catcher’s mitt is that it is not sized the same as a regular fielder’s glove. A positional player’s glove is sized by the length from the top to the bottom. Catcher’s mitts are sized differently because they are sized by the circumference of them.

    Youth players just starting out in little league will usually choose a glove size that has a circumference around 29 ½” to 30” and teenagers and adult gloves can run anywhere from 32” to 34 ½” depending on a person’s hand size.

    Here is a typical size chart for catcher’s mitts based on age:

    • 7 or Under
      29.5” – 30″
    • 8 to 10
      30” – 31″
    • 11 to 13
      30” – 32.5″
    • 14 and Up
      32” – 34.5″

    The importance of sizing a catcher’s mitt properly for you or your child cannot be emphasized. The fit is critical to how well you can control a catcher’s mitt and field the position.

  2. Webbing

    Any type of catcher’s mitt you choose will either have open or closed webbing. For the most part catcher’s mitts have closed webbing because that type of webbing is much more durable than open type webbing is. You can find some catcher’s mitts with predominantly closed webbing that do have some open spots where you can see the ball in the glove if you prefer to have that option.

    The only way you will ever find more open webs on catchers mitts is if you pay to have them custom built for you.

  3. Padding

    If a baseball is thrown to you hard enough when you are catching it’s going to sting a little when you catch it. It is part of the job when you play behind the plate. A glove that has a thicker pocket and good padding elsewhere in it will help minimize sting and protect your hand as you play this tough position.

  4. Adjustability

    We have mentioned a few times in this buying guide the importance of ‘fit’ when it comes to wearing a catcher’s mitt. That is why you want any catcher’s mitt that you buy to be slightly adjustable so you can customize its fit to you or your youth baseball player’s hands.

    Adjusting the fit of a catcher’s mitt is done by loosening or tightening the laces that are found in various locations on it. When you are looking at different mitts make sure you not how many different places with lacing there is on a particular catcher’s mitt to make adjustments on it. The more there are the more adjustable that model catcher’s mitt will be.

  5. Pocket

    The pocket size of your catcher’s mitt is important because it helps you better field balls that are thrown in the dirt and spinning and moving because of the way they are pitches. Unfortunately, the pocket size on a catcher’s mitt is somewhat in direct proportion to its circumference. Smaller catchers’ mitts tend to have smaller pockets but there is some slight variation between models so look for this if you want as big a pocket as possible for your hand size.

  6. Material

    There are basically 4 types of materials that baseball gloves are constructed out of:

    • Synthetic
      This is a great material for young baseball catchers with growing hands. This material is lightweight and inexpensive but does not hold up well over a long period of time.
    • Mesh-backed
      These are catchers’ mitts that are mostly leather except for the back which is a synthetic mesh material. These gloves tend to be a little bit lighter in weight than all leather catchers mitts are and they are very comfortable too. The drawback to mesh backed catchers mitts is they are not nearly as durable as their all leather cousins.
    • Soft leathers
      Soft leather is great because it makes for a comfortable catcher’s mitt that requires little or no break-in time. They also are less expensive than durable leather catchers’ mitts. The problem with this material is it does not hold up as well as catchers mitts made out of durable leather do.
    • Durable leathers
      These are the glove material of choice for serious or professional baseball players. They make the most durable catchers mitts, have the most padding and make a nice crisp popping sound when a baseball is caught with them. The drawbacks of this material are it makes these catchers mitts the most expensive ones and they are heavier too.
  7. Warranty

    Why do you need a good warranty when you buy a catcher’s mitt? The best way to answer that question is to consider exactly what your catcher’s mitt will do. Its sole function is to trap hard centered rawhide baseballs that are thrown at a good velocity several hundred times in a game. That adds up to a lot of wear and tear on any baseball mitt.

    Materials can have defects and manufacturing personnel and equipment can have bad days too. You don’t want to have to keep replacing an item that can cost several hundred dollars at your own expense if you did not cause the problem with it. So when shopping for a catcher’s mitt try and purchase one with the longest and most comprehensive warranty possible.

Can Left Handed Players Go Behind the Plate and Catch?

best youth catcher's mittsIt is interesting to note there has not been a catcher that is left handed play in a major league game since 1989.

Some of this has to do with the fact that baseball is a game that was designed based on throwing right handed. It is thought that lefties will have a hard time making throws to first as a catcher, 3rd baseman, second baseman or shortstop because it takes longer to throw across their bodies.

There is no rule that says a lefty can’t play behind the plate. So why is it then that there are no left-handed catchers in major league baseball? The answer to that is it has more to do with perception and tradition than anything else. Most baseball players choose their positions at an early age and most lefties are immediately switched to other positions besides catcher based on traditional baseball thinking.

What may be the biggest reason why you don’t want to be a catcher if you are a left-handed throwing baseball player? You will have big problems trying to find a catcher’s mitt that fits on your right hand so you can play the position.

You can also find our in-depth review of the best baseball bats by clicking here!

Best Catcher’s Mitt Comparison Chart

PRODUCTPRICESIZEHAND ORIENTATIONMATERIALCOLORFEEL
AllStar CM3000SBT 33.5" Catcher's Mitt
$$$$$33.5"Right hand throwerTan Leather in Palm Black Leather on Back AddsBlack / BrownExtra Stiff
Wilson A2000 Pro Stock Pudge 32.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
$$$$32.5"Right hand throwerPro Stock(TM) LeatherBlack / BrownUnmatched feel
All-Star Pro-Advanced 33.5 Inch CM3100SBT Baseball Catcher's Mitt
$$$33.5"Right hand throwerLeatherBlack / BrownStiff
Mizuno Samurai Pro 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
$$$34''Right hand throwerFull Grain Leather ShellBlack Stiff
Akadema APP240 ProSoft Catcher's Mitt
$$33.5"Left Hand / Right hand throwerSelect Steerhide LeatherBlack Game Ready
Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Youth Catcher's Mitt
$$32"Right hand throwerU.S. Steerhide Leather Construction (Palm and Web) with AkademaLyte Leather on Back to Reduce WeightBrownGame Ready
Mizuno 34" World Win GXC75 Catcher's Mitt
$$34"Right hand throwerTop quality leather and utilizing cutting edge innovationsBlack / BrownGame Ready
Rawlings Renegade Series Catcher’s Mitt, 32.5-Inch
$32.5''Right hand throwerHigh Density Leather Palm Leather Shell & LacingBlack Game Ready
Mizuno Supreme GXC94 Catcher's Mitt
$33.5''Right hand throwerFull Grain Leather ShellBlack Game Ready
Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher's Mitt
$32.5''The glove will be on the left hand of the player and they will throw with their right hand.ParaShock Palm PadBlack / BrownGame Ready

Summing up Our Thoughts on Catcher’s Mitts

Having the right catcher’s mitt to play the game of baseball in is ultra-important to fielding that position correctly. You have so many choices of catcher’s mitts available to you it’s not always easy to tell which models are good or poor ones.

With that being said, you will find that any of the best catcher’s mitts that we reviewed for you will be a great purchase for you. If you don’t like any of the models that we reviewed then use the information in the buying guide to help you find the best youth catcher’s mitt or adult catcher’s mitt for your needs. Getting this purchase right is critical if you or your youth baseball player want to excel at playing behind the plate.

Leave a Reply