Baseball Cleat Buying Guide of 2017 & Reviews (Baseball vs Soccer)

best baseball cleatsBaseball is a great game that is enjoyed by millions all over the world. As such it is also a game that is played under a variety of field and weather conditions. That means that you should be concerned with what you wear on your feet when you play the game. That is why we have taken the time to find what we feel are some of the best baseball cleats you will find in the marketplace and do a comprehensive review on them.

We will also provide you with some tips on what to look for when buying a pair of cleats to play baseball in. With all this information you should easily be able to find a baseball cleat that suits your playing style and local field conditions just fine.

We’ve also compiled a definitive list of the 1o BBCOR Baseball Bats money can buy.

Here is what we think are the 10 best baseball cleats that are sold in the sports marketplace these days:

Baseball Cleat Reviews

  • 4.5 Customer Rating
  • NIKE MEN’S TROUT 2 PRO BASEBALL CLEAT
  • PRICE $
  • SIZE : 7 D (M ) US 12 D (M ) US
  • TYPE : METAL
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic-And-Mesh
  • FETURES : * Phylon midsole for lightweight cushioning and comfort * TPU plate with nine cleat configuration for excellent traction and durability
  • Color : Black / Volt / White
  • 4.6 Customer Rating
  • UNDER ARMOUR MEN’S UA LEADOFF BASEBALL CLEATS
  • PRICE $
  • SIZE : Between 6.5 D (M ) US and 8 D (M ) US
  • TYPE : Rubber molded cleats
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic
  • FETURES : * Combination of UA engineered leather & nubuck upper offers comfort & maximum durability * Abrasion-resistant toe piece delivers protection & durability for medial toe drag
  • Color : Black / White
  • 5.0 Customer Rating
  • ADIDAS MENS ENERGY BOOST ICON LOW METAL CLEATS
  • PRICE $$
  • SIZE : Between 8 D (M ) US and 13.5 D ( M) US
  • TYPE : Metal
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic
  • FETURES : * Synthetic nubuck with SHOCKWEB perforations * Revolutionary full-length boost midsole *External heel clip
  • Color : Black / Red
  • 5.0 Customer Rating
  • UA HARPER ONE MID ST BASEBALL CLEATS
  • PRICE $$$
  • SIZE : Between 7 D (M ) US and 13 D ( M) US
  • TYPE : N / A
  • MATERIAL : Charged Cushioning midsole High rebound Super Foam insole
  • FETURES : * One-piece woven performance upper * Internal fit sleeve delivers a snug customized fit & lightweight breathable comfort * Adjustable ankle strap
  • Color : Black, Black
  • 4.3 Customer Rating
  • JORDAN IV RETRO MCS MENS BASEBALL SHOES
  • PRICE $$$
  • SIZE : 7 D (M ) US
  • TYPE : Molded
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic-And-Leather
  • FETURES : * Air cushioned sole * Molded TPU cleat with Power Channel technology * 12 studs
  • Color : Gym Red/White

NIKE MEN’S TROUT 2 PRO BASEBALL CLEAT

nike-mens-trout-2-pro-baseball-cleatIf you are looking for a stylish, functional and affordable baseball shoe with metal cleats then you should take a closer look at this fine model from Nike. They are a shoe that is endorsed by one of Major League Baseball’s best players Mike Trout. It really is a quality baseball shoe for the price.

They feature six long cleats and a few other shorter ones which are great when playing on grass or soft dirt fields. Their synthetic and mesh construction help give them good support and also lets your foot breathe a little when you are wearing them.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    The fit on these is exceptional and they are very comfortable for an inexpensive shoe when wearing them. Most of us thought the fact they lace up over the ankle makes them fit and feel even then many lower height shoes we tried on.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Maybe a few of us who tried these are on a little old school but we thought the color scheme on these was a little loud. Looks wise they are definitely not for everyone with the large amount of bright yellow they have in their color scheme.

    Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

UNDER ARMOUR MEN’S UA LEADOFF BASEBALL CLEATS

Under Armour Men's UA Leadoff Low RM Baseball CleatsUnder Armour has done a very nice design job with this model cleat. This all plastic cleat was built for superior traction when playing baseball under all different kinds of field conditions. They are also much safer than wearing all-metal cleats too.

The hard plastic cleats are attached to an all rubber so to allow for maximum flexibility and comfort. These baseball shoes are not only built for traction but also designed to let you easily pivot your foot in a motion that is often used when both fielding and batting during a baseball game.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    We loved the blend of materials that were used in the construction of these cleats. You have a mixture of leather, mesh, and nubuck that makes these cleats comfortable, breathable and durable. It is very hard to beat that combination in a baseball cleat.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Low cleats do not offer enough ankle support for some users and these were no different in that respect. So if you have bad ankles you may want to opt for a mid-high baseball cleat. They also seemed to run a little bit on the big side.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

ADIDAS MENS ENERGY BOOST ICON LOW METAL CLEATS

adidas Men's Energy Boost Icon Baseball CleatsThis is an excellent pair of metal baseball cleats that Adidas has designed here. It has a cleat design that will really dig into the ground under all different types of ground conditions to provide you superior traction when batting or playing in the field. These are a very nice all-around cleat for sure.

They use a variety of materials in their construction in order to keep them lightweight, durable comfortable and breathable all at the same time. These shoes are not only comfortable because of the material on the outside but they are also nicely padded in the just the right places on the inside.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    Not only are these cleats very functional when it comes to the game of baseball but they are also really sharp looking too. We thought they were one of the better-looking baseball shoe models we tried on. They come in a large assortment of colors so you should be able to find a pair that will go with just about any uniform.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    The only complaint we had about these is that the sole was a little stiffer than some of us liked to see on a baseball shoe but that may be an acceptable tradeoff for the fine support they have.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

UA HARPER ONE MID ST BASEBALL CLEATS

UA Harper One Mid ST Baseball CleatsIf you put one of the best players in Major League Baseball name on a product you better make it a good product and Under Armour has succeeded nicely with that here. These are a very high-quality baseball shoe, to say the least.

They feature an all one-piece upper that is both lightweight and comfortable. The superior metal cleat design gives you good traction but still lets you pivot nicely as you play the game too. The inside of the shoe is actually more of a comfortable insert which is unique for baseball cleats. There is also very little shock on your feet as you are running around playing in these.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    By far the best thing about these metal cleats is the level of comfort they gave us when wearing them. The feel of them when on more closely resembles a comfortable lightweight workout shoe as opposed to a heavy bulky baseball cleat like others that we tested.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    What is the most obvious drawback with these high-quality baseball shoes? Many of us agreed it was the somewhat higher price tag than similar shoes that we tested. They really are a well-made baseball shoe, though.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

JORDAN IV RETRO MCS MENS BASEBALL SHOES

Jordan IV RETRO MCS mens baseball-shoesSince when do you design a great baseball shoe and then put a basketball players name on it? You do that when that player is named Michael Jordan. They feature the ultimate in comfort with their soft leather and synthetic uppers and the air cushioned sole in them adds to their comfort too.

This baseball shoe features nice 12 heavy plastic studs in all for superior traction when playing. Not only are they comfortable but they are also a very stylish shoe that comes in a variety of different colors. Everyone should be able to find them in a color that appeals to them.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    The fit and feel of these excellent metal baseball cleats are outstanding for sure. When your foot is in them it feels like there is absolutely no pressure on them even when these baseball cleats are laced up tight.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Some of us really do not like the plastic pieces that the laces go through in a couple of places on this shoe. It kind of cheapens the look of this fine baseball shoe a little and also makes them less comfortable in those areas.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

  • 4.5 Customer Rating
  • NIKE MEN’S SLASHER BASEBALL CLEATS
  • PRICE $
  • SIZE : 9 D (M ) US 13 D (M ) US
  • TYPE : METAL
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic leather and mesh uppers
  • FETURES : * Phylon™ midsole * Five metal cleats
  • Color : Black/Metallic Silver
  • 4.4 Customer Rating
  • MIZUNO MEN’S 9 SPIKE ADV BASEBALL CLEAT
  • PRICE $$
  • SIZE : Between 6.5 D (M ) US and 13 D ( M )US
  • TYPE : Molded
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic
  • FETURES : * Rubber/Synthetic sole * Baseball specific cleat with rubber studs to provide comfort and durability for all field types * 9 spike advanced outsole designed for baseball * Full length midsole for maximum comfort
  • Color : Black / White
  • 3.8 Customer Rating
  • NIKE AIR JORDAN 7 RETRO METAL BASEBALL CLEATS
  • PRICE $$$
  • SIZE : 12
  • TYPE : Metal
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic
  • FETURES : * Encapsulated Air-Sole unit and nine strategically placed cleats * Strategically placed TPU overlays
  • Color : BLACK WHITE
  • 5.0 Customer Rating
  • ASICS MEN’S CROSSVICTOR LT BASEBALL SHOE
  • PRICE $
  • SIZE : Between 6 D (M ) US and 12 D ( M) US
  • TYPE : Metal
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic leather
  • FETURES : * Imported * Synthetic sole * 10mm heel gradient shifts body mass forward reducing strain on lower limbs * Solyte polymer spike plate
  • Color : Black/Black
  • 4.7 Customer Rating
  • NEW BALANCE MEN’S PL4040V3 TPU BASEBALL SHOE
  • PRICE $$$
  • SIZE : Between 5 D (M ) US and 16 2E US
  • TYPE : Tetra polyurethane molded cleats
  • MATERIAL : Synthetic
  • FETURES : * Synthetic sole * Full length REVlite RC midsole * Fantom fit upper * Debris free tongue
  • Color : Navy / White

NIKE MEN’S SLASHER BASEBALL CLEATS

Nike Men's Slasher Baseball CleatsThis is a stylish and very functional pair of low height pair of baseball shoes that Nike has made here. They our very high quality like you have come to expect from all the products this reputable shoe and sport manufacturer makes.

These cleats are very comfortable when worn and the cleat design digs in nicely but also allows you the freedom to pivot your foot if you need to. These baseball cleats are also designed to let your foot breathe when they are being worn to further enhance the comfort when wearing them.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    The best thing about these shoes is how solidly built they are. They are reinforced in all the right places such as the tongue, toe, and heel of the shoe. Even though they are reinforced in these areas it does not take away at all from the comfort when you are wearing these fine baseball shoes.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Don’t be fooled by the photos into thinking these are plastic baseball cleats because they use a combination of metal and plastic in the cleat construction. So if you play in a baseball league that does not allow metal cleats, you will not be allowed to use these in that league.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

MIZUNO MEN’S 9 SPIKE ADV BASEBALL CLEAT

Mizuno Men's 9 Spike ADV Franchise 8 BK Baseball CleatThese are an excellent low cut pair of baseball shoes that the reputable baseball company Mizuno has made. They really put a lot of thought and effort into everything they design and these baseball cleats reflect that. It is a very comfortable and high-quality shoe.

Mizuno has done a nice job on these shoes all the way from the flexible rubber soled to the light and comfortable upper part of the shoe. They are also an incredibly stylish shoe when worn and they come in a variety of different colors to choose from.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    It seems like Mizuno has put a lot of thought into the cleat design on these shoes. They have a little different feel than the other shoes with plastic cleats we tested. It just seems like they are more outward on the shoe so they dig into the ground quicker and make it easier to pivot on them too.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Some of us were worried about the accuracy of the sizing that Mizuno has for this shoe. A few of us felt they were a little snug and felt they run one size smaller than what is listed on the shoe.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

NIKE AIR JORDAN 7 RETRO METAL BASEBALL CLEATS

NIKE AIR JORDAN 7 RETRO METAL BASEBALL CLEATS BLACK WHITE 684943 010 SIZE 12If comfort is what you seek from a baseball shoe then look no further than these classic shoes from Nike. This shoe has many of the same great comfort features that are found in the Air Jordan line of basketball shoes that they make. They combine styling with comfort to produce a very good quality baseball shoe here.

These spikes will also let you dig in nicely as you run around in them but also leave your feet free enough to turn in them too without constraint. They are not only comfortable to your feet but they are a very stylish baseball shoe that is comfortable to your eyes also.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    The comfort of these is amazing when they are on your feet. It is like wearing a soft gel pack around each foot. They have great support in all the right paces and they are very lightweight and soft too. The feel of them is more like slippers than baseball cleats.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Although these shoes are pretty amazing we still thought they were a little on the pricey side. Not everyone will be able to fit a pair in their budget and these are really for someone that takes their baseball very seriously.

    Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

ASICS MEN’S CROSSVICTOR LT BASEBALL SHOE

ASICS Men's Crossvictor LT Baseball ShoeIf Batman was a baseball player then these all black and stylish baseball cleats would be his shoe of choice for sure. They look awesome done up in the different shades of black on them. Not to mention, they are also a very easy baseball cleat to keep clean and looking good.

These shoes are very solidly built considering how lightweight they are. Asics has done a nice job of putting these together with both sturdy and breathable materials in order to be able to accomplish that. The foot cushioning that these have is also very well designed, to say the least.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    These shoes are extremely lightweight and comfortable. They have an incredibly light and free feeling when they are on. It is almost as if you are not wearing a baseball cleat when they are on.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Although not many low cut pair of baseball shoes support the ankle well, these are so lightweight it seems as if they don’t support the ankles at all. If you are a player that requires additional ankle support these are not the baseball cleats of choice for you.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

NEW BALANCE MEN’S PL4040V3 TPU BASEBALL SHOE

New Balance Men's PL4040V3 TPU Baseball ShoeHere is a pair of baseball cleats that feel more like a running shoe than a baseball shoe. If you or someone in your family likes to swipe some bases from time to time then these will help. They are incredibly lightweight and comfortable for a baseball cleat.

This is not only a comfortable shoe but it is a stylish one as well. They come in a variety of several different colors too. These baseball cleats are also nicely reinforced in the areas that take the most wear on a baseball shoe.

  • What we liked about these cleats

    New balance is known for the comfort in their running shoes and they have certainly carried that over into this line of baseball shoes. Many of us could not say enough about how comfortable these New Balance baseball cleats are.

  • Potential drawbacks with them

    Some of us who tried these on felt that these New Balance performance baseball shoes were a little narrow on our feet. You certainly don’t want a baseball cleat that is too tight. So check them out good before wearing them in case they have to be returned for a different size pair.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

BASEBALL CLEATS BUYING GUIDE

BASEBALL CLEATS BUYING GUIDEYou should never just go to the store or shop online and buy the first pair of cleats you come across. You also don’t want to buy a pair of cleats just because everyone else has them either because what works for them might not be a good fit for you. So what should you do to find the right pair of cleats for yourself? The answer is to narrow down your choices by narrowing your baseball cleat search down to a few key characteristics.

Here are the key characteristics you want to look at when it comes to buying a new pair of baseball cleats:

  • Price

    Price is always going to be a factor for most people when making any purchase and it’s no different when you are buying a pair of baseball shoes. It is always a good idea to set a budget before you start shopping for any pair of baseball cleats. Be realistic when setting this budget and only choose an amount that you can afford to spend. Once your budget is set then stick to it. This will help you keep from wasting time look at baseball cleats that do not fall within your assigned budget range.

  • Type of Cleat

    You will have two types of cleats to choose from and each has its advantages and disadvantages. Here they are:

  • Metal

    At one time this was the only type of baseball cleat you could find but not anymore. They are better than rubber or plastic cleats because they can really dig in hard ground and grass to help secure your footing as you play the game.

    The drawback with them is that they are very dangerous. That is why they are not allowed in many amateur and high school baseball leagues. Check to make sure your league allows metal cleats before you make your purchase.

  • Plastic/Rubber

    These make up the majority of baseball cleat purchases these days. They are very safe to play with and they can be used to get a better grip on a variety of different baseball playing surfaces.

    The drawback with rubber or plastic cleats is they sometimes have trouble penetrating thick grasses or very hard packed dirt.

  • Comfort

    You certainly want to be comfortable when playing the game of baseball so pick a pair of baseball shoes that are easy on your feet while you are doing it. That means picking a pair of cleats that feature such things as rubber soles, padding in the right places and use lightweight materials in their construction. You also want to have a pair of baseball cleats that breathe a little to keep your feet cool as you play too. Comfort is important so make it a priority when selecting your next pair of baseball cleats.

  • Style

    Most of us like to look good in uniform and a pair of baseball cleats that are stylish can really help us do that. Many pairs come in different colors so you can find a pair you like and will go with almost any uniform. Don’t make style a priority but definitely, keep it in mind when shopping.

  • Warranty

    Baseball is a game that tends to be rough on the shoes you play it with. So if you can get a longer warranty on a pair you are about to buy that is never a bad thing. Make sure you check the warranty before purchasing your next pair of cleats.

  • Ease of care

    Let’s face it; baseball is predominantly played on dirt and grass. Those are not exactly the easiest substances to get off your cleats once they get on them. That is why you want a pair of cleats that has a surface that is easy to clean. Synthetics and leathers will usually clean up nicely. Darker color baseball cleats are usually easier to keep clean looking than lighter ones also. Most manufacturers will even list cleaning instructions on the package a pair of cleats comes in or on their website; that will give you a good indication of how hard a particular pair are to keep clean.

So make sure you take these key characteristics of baseball cleats into consideration when you are about ready to purchase a pair of them.

PLASTIC VS METAL CLEATS

Sometimes you do not have a choice when it comes to picking between plastic and metal cleats to play baseball in because many leagues do not even allow the use of metal cleats. That is why it is important to know if the league you are playing in does before you make a new baseball cleat purchase. If the particular baseball league that you do play in does allow metal spikes then you will have a decision to make as to which one you will purchase.

Here are some of the main characteristics of each type of baseball shoe:

  • Metal Cleats

    Let’s face it; metal cleats will do some things that plastic ones can’t. They will really dig into surfaces such as hardpan dirt or thick grasses much better than plastic cleats will. One of the biggest drawbacks you get with metal cleats is that they can be dangerous during collisions on the field; that is why they are banned in many leagues. Metal cleats tend to add less weight to the shoe also.

  • Plastic/Rubber Cleats

    Plastic cleats are not only much safer than metal cleats but they are usually less hard on your feet while playing baseball too. These types of cleats tend to be much more versatile than metal cleats are too and they are never banned in any leagues so you can wear them in the different baseball leagues you play in.

So when you go to make a decision take your time in making it so you don’t get stuck with a pair of cleats you are unhappy with. Or worse even yet, you have to go out and spend even more money on a different style of baseball cleat. Ask your friends you play with why they chose the type of baseball cleat they wear too; this might help you with your decision also.

WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SOCCER AND BASEBALL CLEATS?

difference between soccer and baseball cleatsMany people who pay multiple sports that require cleats wonder why you can’t use a pair of cleats for more than one sport. This is especially true with baseball and soccer players because these sports are played in different seasons so many people play both. It is a very logical question and one that also has a very logical answer.

The answer to this is simple really and it comes down to cleat layout and design. Soccer and baseball use different skill sets and so they each require different things from the cleats you wear while playing them. They also are different weights, have support in different areas and are made of different materials. It can even be dangerous to use baseball cleats for playing soccer. Here are the main characteristics of each type of cleat.

  • Soccer Cleats

    The shoes that are worn when playing soccer have to be very flexible. It makes sense when a large majority of the game is played using your feet. This means they usually have much softer soles and use less rigid material in their construction than baseball cleats. Soccer cleats also tend to elevate your foot less because soccer is a game that requires your feet to be almost at ground level when playing it.

  • Baseball Cleats

    Baseball cleats have what is called an extra toe stud; that is what makes them dangerous to use when playing soccer. It is a fact that baseball cleats usually have more support and are more rigid than soccer cleats to because of the way the game is played. Baseball cleat material also tends to not be as flexible.

So while it would be nice to be able to save money and use one pair of cleats for both sports you will be at a competitive disadvantage for one of the sports if you do that. Not to mention many times there are even rules against using a cleat that is not made for the sport you are currently playing.

You may also like: List of best slowpitch softball bats and youth baseball bat reviews of 2017

BEST BASEBALL CLEAT COMPARISON CHART

PRODUCTPRICESIZETYPEMATERIALFEATURESCOLOR
NIKE MEN’S TROUT 2 PRO BASEBALL CLEAT
$7 D (M ) US 12 D (M ) USMETALSynthetic-And-Mesh* Phylon midsole for lightweight cushioning and comfort * TPU plate with nine cleat configuration for excellent traction and durabilityBlack / Volt / White
UNDER ARMOUR MEN’S UA LEADOFF BASEBALL CLEATS
$Between 6.5 D (M ) US and 8 D (M ) USRubber molded cleatsSynthetic* Combination of UA engineered leather & nubuck upper offers comfort & maximum durability * Abrasion-resistant toe piece delivers protection & durability for medial toe dragBlack / White
ADIDAS MENS ENERGY BOOST ICON LOW METAL CLEATS
$$Between 8 D (M ) US and 13.5 D ( M) USMETALSynthetic* Synthetic nubuck with SHOCKWEB perforations * Revolutionary full-length boost midsole *External heel clipBlack / Red
UA HARPER ONE MID ST BASEBALL CLEATS
$$$Between 7 D (M ) US and 13 D ( M) USN / ACharged Cushioning midsole High rebound Super Foam insole
* One-piece woven performance upper * Internal fit sleeve delivers a snug customized fit & lightweight breathable comfort * Adjustable ankle strapBlack, Black
JORDAN IV RETRO MCS MENS BASEBALL SHOES
$$$7 D (M ) USMoldedSynthetic-And-Leather* Air cushioned sole * Molded TPU cleat with Power Channel technology * 12 studsGym Red/White
NIKE MEN’S SLASHER BASEBALL CLEATS
$9 D (M ) US 13 D (M ) US
METALSynthetic leather and mesh uppers* Phylon™ midsole * Five metal cleatsBlack/Metallic Silver
MIZUNO MEN’S 9 SPIKE ADV BASEBALL CLEAT
$$Between 6.5 D (M ) US and 13 D ( M )USMoldedSynthetic* Rubber/Synthetic sole * Baseball specific cleat with rubber studs to provide comfort and durability for all field types * 9 spike advanced outsole designed for baseball * Full length midsole for maximum comfortBlack / White
NIKE AIR JORDAN 7 RETRO METAL BASEBALL CLEATS
$$$12METALSynthetic* Encapsulated Air-Sole unit and nine strategically placed cleats * Strategically placed TPU overlaysBlack / White
ASICS MEN’S CROSSVICTOR LT BASEBALL SHOE
$Between 6 D (M ) US and 12 D ( M) USMETALSynthetic leather * Imported * Synthetic sole * 10mm heel gradient shifts body mass forward reducing strain on lower limbs * Solyte polymer spike plateBlack/Black
NEW BALANCE MEN’S PL4040V3 TPU BASEBALL SHOE
$$$Between 5 D (M ) US and 16 2E USTetra polyurethane molded cleatsSynthetic* Synthetic sole * Full length REVlite RC midsole * Fantom fit upper * Debris free tongueNavy / White

CHOOSE YOUR BASEBALL CLEATS WISELY

You now have a lot of information that you know to help you find the best baseball cleats for yourself. Use it wisely in your purchasing decision because baseball cleats are not an inexpensive item and they are also a very big part of being able to play the game well. Being able to grip and turn without slipping is so crucial at times during play. You also want to be comfortable when you are playing the game for long periods of time and there is nothing that says you can’t look good while playing the game of baseball too.

If you use what you have learned here about baseball cleats you will definitely be able to find a pair that covers all the bases for you. Pardon the pun but it really fits appropriately here.

Leave a Reply